Contrary to prevailing safety narratives, the systemic risk of catastrophic ammonium nitrate (AN) accidents has not diminished over the past century. Applying extreme value theory (EVT) to 39 major accidents (1916–2022), this study challenges traditional bottom-up risk paradigms. Results reveal a constant Poisson hazard rate (λ≈0.23/year) and heavy-tailed casualty severity (GPD, ξ≈1.13), confirming that catastrophic outcomes are an inherent feature of these accidents.
Conventional metrics underestimate this risk. For example, the “shadow mean” reveals a potential 1.5–19 times greater than the sample mean, and societal risk lies within the “intolerable” region per F/N curve analysis. This highlights how reductionist approaches overlook the systemic risk reality, such as the governance failures behind the 218 deaths in Beirut. Our EVT framework offers a necessary top-down tool for risk governance, requiring a shift toward monitoring realized systemic risks rather than simulated and narrative expectations.